Soundcheck Blog: On Site - North Korea

Back From the DPRK

March 3, 2008 – 3:19 pm

deplane_2370.jpg

The New York Philharmonic performed an historic concert in the East Pyongyang Grand Theater. WNYC’s John Schaefer was part of the orchestra’s entourage, and he hosted the concert broadcast. Now, Schaefer’s baaaack. Don’t miss what he had to say about the trip to North Korea in his blog.

    >>View photos from the trip

    >>Read blog post 1: Beijing

    >>Read blog post 2: Dark Side of the Moon

    >>Read blog post 3: The Big Event, Part I

    >>Read blog post 4: The Big Event, Part II

    >>Read blog post 5: Farewell to Pyongyang

    >>WNYC’s Coverage of the North Korean trip

WNYC’s coverage of the NY Philharmonic’s visit to Pyongyang is supported in part by the Kaplen Foundation.

North Korea in pictures (and Beijing too)

February 29, 2008 – 12:28 pm



Lorin Maazel meets the North Korean delegation.
See all photos from Soundcheck On Site: North Korea

Originally uploaded by WNYC’s John Schaefer

Farewell to Pyongyang

February 28, 2008 – 4:53 pm

Our North Korean handlers have been going crazy trying to maintain some semblance of order among the unruly mob that is the international press. But it turns out they will have the last laugh. At 7 am, room phones start to ring. Please pay your room and phone/internet charges between 8 and 8:30 because the buses leave at 9. Well, the itinerary says the buses leave at 10, after breakfast, for the big children’s arts school where a major concert has been organized for the Philharmonic and the press. I tell this to Mr. Lee, who seems momentarily flustered, and I wonder if he is perhaps unused to having people talk back to him. Although I’ve slept just over 2 hours, I had just woken up for some reason a few minutes before, so his call was not quite the rude awakening it would be for many of my colleagues. So I explain that I’m fine with settling my accounts, and since it is the money that he’s really worried about, that’s all he needs to hear.

Once in the lobby, I learn that the handlers actually have our passports, and that the cheap armbands that we paid 30 Euros for to identify us as press must be returned to them - or we pay a 50 Euro fine. At least there’s no surprise settling the room: 80 Euros per night, as promised. Then it’s time to face the internet/phone bill. Actually, this is something I can’t do on an empty stomach - I don’t mind missing sleep but I missed last night’s big banquet here in the hotel because I was in the media center all night, and missing meals makes me very unhappy. So it’s back to the Bizarro Breakfast Buffet, and then on to the communications table (formerly the coat check room.)

I brought 800 Euros to Pyongyang, leaving 640 - about a thousand bucks - for communications charges. It seemed like overkill in NY. Now, having paid the 30 Euro fee for the press application, and for the two passport photos they had to take for said application, I find that I’m short about 500 Euros. Remember, there is no way to acquire hard currency in North Korea. No ATMs, no credit cards. I was just wondering how long I’d be in a North Korean labor camp when I noticed a bunch of unfamiliar numbers of my itemized bill. No, not unfamiliar, exactly, but numbers I know I didn’t call. Then I recognized them: NPR. NPR’s Anthony Kuehn had the spot next to me in the media center, and had obviously used my phone by mistake. Here the minders come in handy - Mr. Lee finds Anthony’s handler, who understands the problem and knows how to explain it to the communications staff. I eventually find Anthony, and he is fine with paying the nearly 300 Euros his calls cost. So now I’m 200 Euros short. But I know they’ll take US dollars. Will they take Chinese ruan? As it turns out, they will. I know that I can get more ruan from an ATM at the Beijing airport, so I give them all my remaining Chinese cash - a bit more than 800 ruan. Having wiped out my Euros and Chinese currency, they start on my few remaining dollars. At this point, the woman relieving me of my troublesome cash actually laughs. I’m just 44 dollars short. Of course, she can’t make change, but I have several 20s and a 5, so that does the trick. Now I can get my passport from Mr. Lee, who sees only a stamped invoice and has no idea of the international quality of the payment.

Sightseeing in Pyongyang and Mr. Sung
Pyongyang City View
The buses again offer us a chance to see some of Pyongyang. We will be going to the conservatory for a children’s event, and “if there’s time,” to Kim Il Sung’s birthplace. That means we don’t stand a chance. But the calendar in my room shows a beautiful photo of Kim Jong Il’s birthplace, a log cabin on the side of a mountain in North Korea. (For those who are hung up on “facts,” he was born in Siberia while his dad, Kim Il Sung, was in exile.) At least we’ll get to see the one structure that everyone has been talking about. Looming over the city skyline is a dark pyramid that must be enormous, even by NY standards. Steve Smith, who went on the sightseeing tour yesterday, reports that it’s the famously unfinished hotel that the Russians started in the 80s and never finished. Because it remains unfinished, he says, it is no longer there as far as the locals are concerned. How they ignore something the size of a small mountain in their city is, I guess, a matter of will. Like believing their Dear Leader was born in that log cabin, and personally designed the famed Juche Tower, composed 6 operas, and singlehandedly fixed the acoustics in the theater where we saw the first night’s concert.
Pointy Russian Hotel
For some reason, one of the younger assistant handlers, whom I haven’t seen before and will call Mr. Sung, has decided to sit and talk with me on the bus. He says the hotel is 100 stories high, and as we approach, I believe him. At the top is an old construction crane, apparently left there when work stopped. Elsewhere on the bus, there is some good-natured ribbing going on. At least, I hope it’s good-natured, since it’s aimed at me. Apparently my various phone reports in the media center these past few nights have been a little louder than I thought, and some colleagues are having fun telling me how I have “a strong voice” and “it carries well” and “you should be in radio.” I’m feeling slightly gauche and embarrassed, but point out feebly that my end of the connection had a lot of static and it was hard to hear.
Rally Central
Mr. Sung is actually quite forthcoming about his life - a rare change from the other minders. He wants to know where I live, whether I have family, and seems to fully expect me to ask him similar questions in return. (He was born and raised in Pyongyang, is single, likes working for the Ministry of Culture because he occasionally meets people from outside, has studied English for 3 years but rarely has a chance to use it and is glad of this opportunity. He works weekdays and Saturday mornings and gets 8 to 10 days off a year, paid vacation. He admires the conservatory kids we’re about to see but wasn’t able to go himself because he wasn’t talented enough.). I ask if he’s ever been out of the country. He nods solemnly: once, when he went to China. I ask what the major jobs in Pyongyang are - is there industry? He says the industry is outside the city. Inside, government jobs are common. Over the course of the day, I try to get a sense of what a real North Korean life might be like. Does he own a TV? (Yes.) Do most people? (Yes. He thinks so.) But in the countryside it’s different, surely? (I’ve heard a UN statistic that only 5 percent of North Koreans have televisions, but officially, North Korea disputes this. Sung says that TV is rare in the countryside.)
Billboard
We pass a movie theater with two posters, a man and a woman, clearly actors. Do North Koreans watch movies? Of course, he says. North Korean movies? Yes, we have big movie studio in Pyongyang, he says. I’m trying to gauge whether any outside ideas are seeping in, so I ask if people watch foreign films. Some Chinese films sometime come in. Hollywood, no. You like to watch films you understand, he says. I nod. What about South Korea? Do you get to watch any South Korean films? Or TV shows?

I’m pushing it here, and Sung knows it. Watching South Korean TV is a crime punishable by forced labor. For once, he pauses and is clearly uncomfortable. I could not answer that, he says; I do not know. I think we do get some South Korean films though. Fair enough, I think. I’ve met a young man who seems genuine and friendly - I’m not going to trick him into saying something treasonous. Besides, we’ve arrived.

The children’s theater is a sumptuous, gigantic building with a theater full of disappearing wings, sliding floors, scrims - all the trappings of a truly professional theater. And the kids are amazing. Singers, musicians, dancers, acrobats - and they’ve worked up two songs for their American guests. Jingle Bells and My Darling Clementine. The words are unrecognizable and the melodies are orchestrated to truly saccharine heights - much the way Korean folk music is treated in the popular light classical style. Everything is precise and the kids seem as professional as the adults. Sung tells me, when I ask how they’re chosen, that they volunteer. And they pick what they will study. It’s essentially a big after-school program, and the Mangyongdae School is nothing if not big. There are hundreds of Koreans in the audience in addition to most of the Philharmonic, many with spouses and other family members, and the press.
north_korea_kids_400.jpg
The performance begins with the song “Best Is My Country,” with kids materializing out of wings and walls until there seem to be hundreds on the stage. Later, a girls chorus sings “Generalissimo Kim Il Sung Dance With Us” and the audience dutifully bursts into applause at the Great Leader’s name. A gymnastic routine is called “We Are Masters of the Future” and features kids doing things with hula hoops that defy the laws of gravity and logic. The grand finale is the song “We Are Faithful Only To General Kim Jong Il,” which produces an inevitable outpouring of applause when the title is flashed on the stage. And when, at the end, the back of the stage becomes a huge photo of the Dear Leader, the audience erupts. The kids, clearly inspired, bring down the house with the final chorus. Then, in a strange echo of last night’s memorable ending, the kids begin to file out, waving as they go. This is clearly choreographed, and the parents and others are on their feet, as are the Americans. And the Philharmonic members are waving back. This is not choreographed. And so several hundred kids will have this memory, of the despised Americans who came and waved to them. Again, somewhere down the road, maybe many years down the road, that memory may be a little crack in the door of this closed nation.
billboard happy kids
On the other hand, my overwhelming reaction is just how creepy this is. They start drinking the Kool-Aid at an awfully early age here, and Kim’s cult of personality is a very effective and very pernicious cult. It would be interesting to see what Pyongyang looks like next week, when we’re all gone. We’ve learned that most of the virulent anti-American billboards have been removed, though one, of a huge fist crushing an American GI, remains. Everyone wants a photo of it, but it’s at a weird angle to the street and as the buses pass it’s too hard to really photograph effectively. Will the others stay down, or will they be right back up?

Whatever happens, we won’t be there to see it. The buses take us directly to the tarmac and our waiting plane. There is no ceremony as we say goodbye with varying degrees of sincerity to our guide/handlers (I wish Mr. Sung many more chances to use his language skills, and thank him for his company, and mean it), and trickle up the stairs. There is one final piece of surrealism for this day - the flight to Seoul is 50 minutes long. In less than an hour, we have moved into another world, and apparently another century, as Seoul spreads out beneath the plane and spreads into the sea with a colorful, geometric series of causeways, gas distribution rigs, etc.

From North to South to Beijing Again

But while still en route, a wonderful thing happens: I get my blackberry back. My baby, I cry when it’s passed to me. My baby is back! I have become a hopeless addict (hence the nickname Crackberry), and like Gollum in The Lord Of The Rings, I can’t help feeling I’ve got my Precious back. Plus I can actually finish these damn blogs.

I’m in Seoul only to connect to a flight back to Beijing. Everyone else is staying for the NY Phil’s concert there. A few hours later, I’m back where this whole thing started - same hotel, and apparently, the same neon sign over my head saying “I am a fool and I have money! Please part me from it!” Although it was just a few days ago, it seems like last year when I walked out of the hotel only to be continually accosted by young men wanting to practice English by bringing me into their friend/teacher’s store, old women grabbing my arm and pointing to their identical trinkets saying “cheap! Look, cheap!” (had to agree with them there), and young women asking if I wanted “Chinese girlfriend.” (One enterprising woman would not be so easily brushed aside, upping the ante to “hotel sex.” On the theory that I was too stupid to understand the girlfriend part.)

The first person I meet, before I even leave the terminal, presents himself as a taxi driver. But he leads me to a different door, and a car that is clearly private. So, car service then. I ask the fare, and it’s about four times what the taxis charge. When I tell him this he says that’s not true, I’m mistaken, etc. I walk away.

After checking in, I leave the hotel through the basement entrance to the underground mall. There’s a supermarket where I can buy decent English ale. As soon as I open the door and enter the mall a young woman comes striding purposely up to me. “You have an interesting look,” she announces. “Interesting hair. Are you musician? We could have a drink.” On the one hand, it’s just too annoying to leave the hotel - on the other, there’s a certain wild wild west quality to modern Beijing - changing from a closed city to an Olympic-hosting cosmopolitan center that looks like midtown Manhattan - that feels like home, like New York in the 70s perhaps. I think about Pyongyang - where are the hustlers and the hookers? The casino was squirreled away in the hotel basement. Where do you go if you’re gay, or religious, or otherwise out of step with a lockstep society? People are the same everywhere, so all of these groups must be hidden somewhere in the darkened floors of Pyongyang. When change comes, someday, will Pyongyang look like Beijing? I regard my unwanted companion (she does walk fast, because she’s keeping up with me) for a brief second, which is normally a mistake, then smile and shake my head no, and head into the supermarket.

If you do not see the video please install the latest flash player.

Pyongyang, day 2: the big event, Part II

February 28, 2008 – 2:30 pm

So, after all this, what about the concert itself? Well, you can presumably hear it by clicking on the link to our broadcast of it elsewhere on this website (ed.’s note: our broadcast window has expired. Check the New York Philharmonic’s site, which has full online audio/video of the event: www.nyphil.org.) I will say that the performance was not perfect. There was some weirdness in the first section of the Gershwin and a few flubs in the Dvorak, for example, but no one cared and it really didn’t matter. This was history, and everyone knew it.

This audience also rose instantly when the DPRK anthem began, and stood ramrod straight through the American anthem as well, but there was little evidence of uncertainty here - the music ended and they applauded and the concert began in earnest. Lorin Maazel had apparently used his afternoon wisely - his attempts at Korean this time provoked genuine amusement and applause. He did offer an unusual introduction to An American In Paris: someday, he said, some composer might write a piece called Americans In Pyongyang. Now, if he’d said “An American in Pyongyang,” that would’ve had a friendly, musical travelogue feel to it. But “Americans In Pyongyang” sounds more like a threat. Fortunately, everyone understood what he meant, and the three encores went off without a hitch - and without the six Korean wind players. “Arirang” went on much longer, it seemed to me, but the audience, recognizing the tune instantly, loved it. And then, when the piece and the concert ended, came the moment that everyone is still talking about now, a day later.

The Moment That Everyone is Still Talking About

It started normally enough - Maazel left the stage, thunderous applause (plus a bravo or two - that must’ve been the Western diplomatic corps, North Koreans do not shout like that) continued, he returned for a bow, the orchestra stood and bowed, flowers were presented - all the usual routine. Except the applause didn’t stop. Even after Maazel left again and came back, bowed, and left yet again. Finally, the orchestra had to make a decision. After much exchanging of confused glances, concertmaster Glenn Dicterow stood up, and musicians began to move off the stage. As they did, much of the front section of the audience began waving goodbye. Clearly caught by surprise, some of the musicians started waving back. A few were clearly starting to cry. This was too good to miss - I gathered my gear and ran backstage (I edited that part out for the broadcast) and grabbed Jon Deak, the eloquent associate principal bassist of the Phil, whose voice I used at the top of the broadcast musing about stepping off the plane onto North Korean soil. He was just gathering himself together. Nearby was Katherine Greene, one of the top violists, also just gathering herself. Both were moved by the same thing: not the movement of forces of history, and not even by the music they’d just played, but by the personal connection they’d just experienced. The feeling of gratitude and goodwill coming from an audience that might’ve been expected to be polite and nothing more. If this latest example of Ping Pong Diplomacy does anything, it will be because two groups of people make connections, whether through music (the Boston Symphony in China in 1973, the Philadelphians in the Soviet Union in 1959, the NY Phil here), or sports (the American table tennis team’s visit to China in the early 70s), or some other field. The North Koreans, presented for the first time with a group from the country they’ve been taught from birth to distrust and hate, responded with an unexpected and spontaneous display of affection. And the orchestra, some of whom were becoming quite skittish around the unnatural amount of media attention and perhaps feeling the weight of unreasonable historic/political expectations, found that at the end of the day they’d been right all along - it was about the music touching people and forging a connection.
Members of the New York Phil wave(Photo: REUTERS/David Gray)
Okay, time to cut the swelling melodramatic background music. The concert ends, but now the real work begins. Morning Edition needs something, so does CBS, and American Public Media’s “Performance Today,” and Soundcheck, and the blogs, in bits and pieces if time allows - and there’s the concert broadcast to finally deal with. Has Larry Rock figured it out? Turns out he has - using the same internet technology I’d been unable to purchase the day before.

The concert will have to be sent back home in pieces, in compressed pieces, and Ed Haber and Eileen Delahunty will have to piece it back together for airtime.

What the Late-Night Recon Mission Uncovered

Around midnight, with two reports done and several to go, and the music en route to NY, I head off to the men’s room. I could go up to my room, but the elevators are slow and that’ll waste 15 minutes. I’m not afraid of the glass-fronted Elevator of Death because at night, that glass wall might as well be black marble: Pyongyang is virtually invisible at night. Like an English city during the Blitz, it is almost completely dark - yet another facet of its weird, ghost-town vibe.

Anyway, the signs say there’s a bathroom downstairs. So here’s the scene: late at night. The hotel lobby is dark and quiet. The front desk seems unstaffed. (Guess they don’t get unexpected guests here.). The little souvenir and bottled water shops are closed and dark. Down the stairs, there’s a Chinese restaurant closing up, a few Australian journalists sitting at the lone table in front, finishing their drinks. I follow the signs down a quiet hallway that turns, turns again, and leads to… A casino. Blackjack, baccarat, roulette - the tables all stand empty and silent, with hotel staff behind most of them. It’s like something out of Stephen King’s “The Shining,” his book about a writer going crazy in an apparently empty hotel in the Rockies. Here, in this eerie scene in a remote hotel in one of the world’s most repressive states, I wonder if I’m going crazy. It feels like every eye is following me as I head to the men’s room. When I come out, they’re all still there - I am not hallucinating. Questions pile on top of each other: who’s this for? What does the “house” use for money? So many questions, but I’m not sure I want the answers. And I still have hours of work to do.

That’s a Wrap

At least I’m feeling a bit better about some of tonight’s reports, and I think the concert will sound good. But I can’t get the photos off my camera, onto the laptop, and into an email for these blogs. Or I can, but it’s so slow. At 4am, I decide that the 3 or 4 photos I’ve managed to attach will just have to do until I get back to NY. It has been a long and surreal day, and we have a tight schedule and an early start tomorrow. It is time, finally, for bed.

Pyongyang, day 2: the big event, part I

February 27, 2008 – 11:29 am

Day 2 starts just a few hours after a frustrating day 1 ends. Upon waking, no tech fairies have appeared to magically make connections work, though Larry Rock has been making reassuring noises in his emails to NY, which I’m cc’d on. The banquet room has been set up for a breakfast for the musicians and journalists, and it is further proof of just how hard they’re trying here at the hotel - and how mixed their results are. An omelette chef is a welcome sight, and there is fruit, both familiar and unfamiliar. Also strange, presumably Korean dishes with mushrooms, beans, corn, and pickles. Some of these are pretty good, though not what we’d expect for breakfast. Under the category of “just plain wrong” I’d put the macaroni and cheese (the sign says “semolina gratin”), the skewered mutton (motto: “tough leathery meat - it’s not just for dinner anymore!”), and various other Western chafing dish entrees that would appear at your local Rotary Club dinner. But there is juice and yogurt, and water - thank heavens. You cannot, of course, drink the water in North Korea, and for someone like me who drinks a LOT of water, this is a problem. Steve Smith of Time Out NY tells me there’s a shop in the back of the elevator bank that has bottled water - this is welcome news because I can’t very well walk out of the banquet room with a bunch of their glass bottles of water.

Steve also says he was awakened by a phone call to his room: his handler needed him to fill out a press form and pay 30 Euros (almost 50 bucks) for a “press pass” - a flimsy blue armband. Sure enough, when I get back to the lobby Mr Lee, my guide/minder, has a form and wants 30 Euros. No one knew anything about this, and with no chance of replacing hard currency here, there is a danger that we may now be short when payment time comes tomorrow. But as we’d been warned, there is a bureaucracy here that needs to be fed, and a certain amount of forebearance was necessary to get along.

The buses return to take the musicians to the dress rehearsal and the journalists on a sightseeing tour. This has surprised many of us - we assumed we would be kept away from much of the city, but the itinerary includes several of these opportunities and the handlers are urging us to come and take photos and see as much of the city as we have time for. It sounds good, and I will do that when I have time, but for the morning I need to be in the East Pyongyang Grand Theater with the band. If they’re running the whole show, as planned, that will tell me how long the breaks between pieces are, where speeches will take place, where I may need to fill a bit of extra time, etc.

Mr. Lee is scandalized. Why won’t I come with the rest of Bus 8? Because I need to see the rehearsal, I explain. I promise I will see the city later, and go onto a bus taking the CNN, Fox, and WFMT folks - all of whom need to see the rehearsal for their own broadcasts - to the theater.

Afternoon Rehearsal

It is Grand, all right. You could probably put two Carnegie Halls inside, and still have room to lay a football field on top. The lobby is a towering affair, and like most public buildings in Pyongyang, it is unheated. The hall itself is warm though. (I should mention that the hotel rooms were not just heated, but hot. Not that I was complaining. The heat and the stiffness of the small bed meant that no matter how little sleep you got, getting up in the morning was kind of a relief.)
New York Philharmonic rehearsal
The orchestra is there, and they are indeed running through the whole show, in what turns out to be a splendid hall that, like most of the better buildings we’ve seen, is a reminder of North Korea’s glory days as an economic powerhouse in the 60s and 70s, while South Korea’s economy was languishing. By the “whole show,” I mean on-stage remarks, translations, etc. Of course what happens now will change tonight, but it’ll give me a general idea of what to expect… And how the crowd might react. Because the hall is packed. Every seat is filled. NY Phil president Zarin Mehta will tell us later that he was informed that there was enough demand for tickets that they could’ve sold out several additional nights, and obviously some lucky Koreans who couldn’t come to the official concert were able to score seats at the rehearsal, which is in fact now a concert in itself.

So who are these people? All along, we’ve been wondering who would come to the concert. The NY Phil has consistently said it doesn’t know, while hinting at the possibility of “special guests,” but for this morning, these are mostly teachers and library workers, plus a few students.

At the start, after welcoming remarks, the orchestra launches into the DPRK national anthem, and an entire audience jumps to attention in a single motion, as if they were all abruptly pulled up by strings. It’s impressive, and a little creepy. Then, with no real pause, comes the Star-Spangled banner. Everyone remains at attention, and when it’s over… Well, this is what we all wanted to see, isn’t it? How the North Koreans would react to their sworn enemy’s anthem being played on their soil? There is a very brief but immediately palpable moment of uncertainty, and then the audience applauds. Not wildly, but not half-heartedly either. Then another brief moment while the audience decides what to do next. Since the Phil is clearly ready to move on, the crowd sits.

I have to say, the orchestra looked and perhaps sounded a little tired in Beijing. They’ve been touring China for over 2 weeks, and that sort of thing will play havoc with your body clock. I’ve already forgotten what day it is and how long I’ve been here, and Beijing seems very far away. But this morning, now turning to afternoon, they sound pretty damn good. Lorin Maazel’s movements have a crispness about them, and the Lohengrin Act III Prelude by Wagner is gleaming. No doubt why he chose the piece - it’s a showpiece for both the band and the hall.

Dvorak’s New World Symphony sounds great too, and movement 1 leads quickly into the famous Largo, later turned into the Spiritual “Goin’ Home.” Of course, this crowd would have no way of knowing that, but the music has an accessibility that seems to reach them, and when the movement ends, there is a smattering of applause, and I think I hear a bit of embarrassed chuckling. Hey, concert etiquette’s a bitch, as they say.

The media is upstairs in the boxes overlooking the main floor of the hall. Mark Travis, who is doing this evening’s broadcast for Chicago broadcaster WFMT and its network, is doing what I’m doing - scribbling down timings and notes on the ledge, which is almost deep enough to serve as a desk. Which is good, since I have a lifelong fear of heights. The ledge isn’t bothering me since I’m sitting at it and looking out, not down. But CNN’s Christiane Amanpour is in the box next to me, sitting on the ledge, and this is making me very nervous. Finally I tell her so; she laughs and says not to worry, but she’s missing the point - I’m not worried about her, I’m worried about losing my lunch before I’ve even had it. But she does get down off the ledge. At this point a Korean gentleman whom I have not yet met comes into the box, announcing that he was looking for “Mr. John Shaper.” It turns out the Mr. Lee, with only five of his six charges in his sight, needed someone to make sure the sixth wasn’t off fomenting a revolution. Or counter-revolution, as the case may be. He wants me to leave, and I tell him I will be on the bus with these other journalists (indicating the CNN crew, a South Korean TV crew, and Mark), along with their handler - when the rehearsal ends. He looks young (but you know what? They ALL look young. I don’t recall seeing a woman who looked to be over 30, anywhere - all right, what are you people doing with your women when they turn 40?) and out of his depth and I almost feel sorry for him.

Since this is a rehearsal, the orchestra is allowed a break, so there’s an intermission here, which won’t happen tonight. Then it’s Gershwin’s An American In Paris, followed by 3 encores. Twice Lorin Maazel ends his remarks with a word or two in Korean. But his pronunciation is apparently so atrocious that no one seems to understand him, and again there’s some uncertain tittering, followed immediately by good-natured applause. Hey, he tried. And there is an eruption of applause when 6 wind players from the DPRK State Symphony Orchestra appear onstage for the final encore, the beloved Korean folksong “Arirang.” This is unexpected - will this happen tonight too? Again, it’ll be one of those go-with-the-flow things here.

The end of the rehearsal is a bit confusing, because while this has looked and sounded like a concert, it IS after all a rehearsal, and after the final applause, the audience genuinely doesn’t know what to do. Conductor Maazel has heard a few things in both the Gershwin and the Bernstein Candide Overture, which the orchestra plays without a conductor in tribute to the late great maestro, and so everyone politely sits back down and watches the Phil work through a couple of short passages before the rehearsal time runs out. Backstage, I catch up again with concertmaster Glenn Dicterow, who quips, “they’re gonna think we don’t know how to play.”

Sleep deprivation, dehydration, frustration, and stress combine to make the rest of the afternoon a blur. Channel 13, WNET, is doing a live telecast tonight and they had asked me in NY if I would do an on-camera thing for the end of the broadcast. Seemed simple enough, and I wasn’t going to have to worry about how to get the sound back to them, so I agreed. Finding their crew, who were incredibly mobile, was difficult, but I eventually record the thing and immediately regret nearly half of what I said. My throat is dry and while I thought I’d marshalled some coherent thoughts, I sound scattered in my own ears. Kind of like last night’s live reports for Morning Edition and Brian Lehrer. Jeez, when am I gonna pull myself together?

Back at the hotel, it’s back to the phone and the yousendit.com website to rush the music I’ve recorded back to culture editor Allison Lichter, who’s been coordinating all the different shows that want reports from North Korea. But music files are big, so I use a compression program the engineers loaded onto the laptop for just this reason. When uncompressed back home, they’ll sound (in theory) as good as what I started with. Well that actually works. Just one problem - they forgot to install the program on Allison’s computer, so she can’t unpack the files. She’s got my report which I’ve phoned in (starting to really worry about the cost of these calls now, especially since several new sources, including CBS Radio Network, want stuff), but can’t use the music yet. We are 14 hours ahead, though, and Ed Haber, my long-suffering tech director for 25 years of concerts at WNYC, has gotten up early or gone to bed late to unpack the music files; so by 9am, she should have it ready for the late hour of Morning Edition.

Lost Objects and Vertigo

Heading back to my room, on the 32nd floor, I decide to take a photo from the hall window, a kind of Pyongyang vista shot. Again, it’s looking out, not down, so it’s okay. And that’s when I realize I’ve lost my glasses. They were in my coat, and I had them at rehearsal - and I realize that when I did the Channel 13 spot I threw my coat over a chair in the hall and the glasses must’ve fallen out there. Fortunately, we’ll be back there in a while and I’ll just go into the hall before it’s open and look for them.

Heading back down, the doors open to the front elevator. I haven’t been on this one yet. I step in - and the front wall of the front elevator is ALL GLASS. It is part of the front of the building and it’s ALL GLASS AND THIS IS NOT OKAY! Plastered against the back wall and looking resolutely at the doors (can’t look at the wall facing the glass because it’s ALL MIRRORS and definitely NOT COOL EITHER), with my hands and feet beginning to swell, I realize that I am having a tough time going with the goddamn flow.

It doesn’t even occur to me to press a button to get off and wait for any other elevator until it stops on the 7th floor. The doors open onto a dark, completely unlit hallway from which emerge two gentlemen who are not in military uniform but have “I will whup your yankee ass” written all over them. They get in, nod politely, and we ride down in silence. Clearly I was not supposed to get off on 7.

I will later see that we’re not supposed to get off on 17 either, or 18 - both completely dark when staff entered or exited after nightfall. I wonder about 9, though. A North Korean man in his 20s (or maybe he was 50, I’ve given up trying to guess) and a girl about the same age get on one of the elevators that night while I’m riding with two other journalists, and he turns and says ‘it’s alright, she is my wife.” The doors open onto a pitch black 9th floor and they both get off, stifling giggles.

“I Make Radio” & Smuggled Gear

It is time, finally, for the buses to depart for the main event. I’ve got my recording gear and hope to recover my glasses when we get there. But - surprise! - there’s a problem. We need tickets to get out of the freezing lobby and into the warm hall. People are starting to arrive and enter the hall - our buses ran late and my chance of scouring an empty hall for my glasses are diminishing by the moment. But I can’t talk my way past an uncomprehending but unyielding Korean woman (approximate age, 22. Or 63.) The Philharmonic staff, it must be said, have been keeping everyone sane and getting the media what it needs and generally have made this whole thing work. One of them, Michelle Balm, walks around handing out tickets and tells me I have a specific place (as does Mark Travis, who will also need a quiet place to record his broadcast) while the rest of the tickets are general seating. That’s fine, and I run back to the doors only to be denied entrance again. My ageless tormentor pulls at my coat and points to a hallway, and makes it clear that I am to check my coat. I’d heard that this was a common security measure in North Korea, but people are filling the hall and I want to go to the spot where I think I lost my glasses. I try to explain this through a kind of pantomime - forming two circles with my fingers and putting them in front of my eyes is clearly going to be the universal signal for “glasses.” And apparently the rest was the universal signal for “hopeless idiot”. Entry denied.

Rush to coat check. Get my coat check tag. Rush back to door. Turn around and rush back to coat check - I’ve left my envelope full of Euros in the inside pocket, and I don’t want to take any chances. Back to the door. Guess what? The universal signal for “no dice, buster.” What’s the f#*+ing problem now? My bag of recording gear. I now turn to the last resort of the American-in-foreign-language-meltdown mode: I start speaking English, slow and loud. “I am broadcaster,” I announce stupidly. “Make radio. Microphone. Concert! Radio! You will please just shoot me!”

Eventually, Michelle comes and explains to me that she will work it out. How? By enlisting one of her colleagues to carry the bag as her handbag, while I hide the small hard-drive recorder and mike in my pockets and she hides the cable and headphones in her jacket. Brilliant! We cruise right by the Korean Charybdis at the door, who doesn’t even look as we go by. Now, of course, the hall is full. People are milling about and while I drop my ticket near the spot where I think my glasses fell out so I can check on the ground, there is nothing there and no hope of finding them.

So who actually came? Two whole rows were reserved for Ambassadors (according to the seat signs, anyway. I’m sure some family and staff were included). We are still officially at war with North Korea, so the Swedish Embassy handles all American affairs there, and they have invited the diplomats. The Vice Minister of Culture and numerous other high-ranking officials from the ministry are there. So are the patrons of the NY Phil who paid for the costs of this extraordinary addition to the group’s Asian tour. The rest seem to be rank and file North Koreans. Although in Pyongyang, everyone seems to be a government employee in some way. Still, it’s a full house, and the crowd is buzzing.

The Dark Side of the Moon

February 26, 2008 – 6:09 pm

I don’t know what I really expected from North Korea - I pictured it as a steely, grey, cold place: a bleak, barren land with people moving around in a combination of militaristic precision and cult-induced narcosis.
So when we flew in over a bleak, barren landscape with almost no sign of human activity, and landed in Pyongyang’s remote airport under a steely, grey, cold sky, with a stinging snow falling and a huge poster of North Korean founder Kim Il Sung’s face presiding over us, it was strangely comforting. It really did look the way we’ve been taught to think North Korea looks.

Pyongyang Touchdown

Before leaving from Beijing, all of our passports are collected, along with our cell phones and blackberries. Media in North Korea is either completely controlled by the government, or it is not allowed. Cell phones and internet can’t be controlled, so they are illegal. Fortunately, a media center has been set up for us at the hotel, with each journalist supplied with a direct-dial phone, an internet connection, and a mobile phone if needed. Unfortunately, the rates for this gear is daunting (about ten bucks a minute for a phone call to the States) - and it has to be paid in cash, in Euros, which you have to bring into the country with you. The Democratic People’s Republic of Korea is a cash-only society; there are no ATMs and foreigners are forbidden to use the native currency. We are expected to bring “real” money in from outside. This is a real potential problem, but we’ll see how that works out…

Anyway, the press corps descends first, on old-fashioned jet-stairs, right onto the tarmac a good distance from the terminal. There, we amass in the wind-blown snow and watch the deplaning of the NY Philharmonic, allegedly the first major group of Americans to touch down on North Korean soil (hey what were we, chopped liver? I mean, we DID get there first by a good couple of minutes.)New York Philharmonic deplaning This photo-op was planned to be a quick and orderly affair - we all snap away as the musicians come down the stairs; the Vice Minister of Culture welcomes the orchestra and shakes hands with conductor Lorin Maazel, president Zarin Mehta, and chairman Paul Guenther; and then we pile into buses and go to the hotel. (The great irony is that here, in this most closed of countries, we never went through customs, never came near the terminal, never turned in the very important arrival form (”are you bringing weapon, ammunition, killing device, drug, exciter, poison,” etc (’exciter’ must mean ’stimulant’ - right? Or a toddler, maybe? (And if you’re bringing these things into North Korea, would it make it all more fun to answer “yes”? (Sorry for all the parentheses within other parentheses but when you haven’t slept in days it makes your mind kinda jumpy (there’s a name for the affliction that causes people to insert too many parenthetical remarks, by the way, but I forget what it is (and anyway I’m finally ready to wrap up all these digressions and return to the conclusion of my thought. (If I can remember what it was. But first, I have to close all these parentheses. Get ready - here goes…))))))) (Wow, that felt good!) (Sorry.) But the North Koreans, isolated from the wider world for 6 decades, have no clue what they’re in for. If the US or anyone else ever does decide to attack this most militarized of nations, they may want to lead with their press corps. Talk about shock and awe. Just try to tell a wire service photographer, or worse, a network tv cameraman, to stay behind a line or give a subject some room. The scene quickly turns into a free-for-all, until the weather cools people’s enthusiasm enough that we could be loaded onto buses and dispatched with a collective sigh of relief by the airport security detail.

Pyongyang is about 70 kilometers from its airport, and the ride is truly surreal. There is what looks like a small garrison town near the airport, with that mid-20th-century Soviet block architecture and the only splashes of color coming from the huge agitprop posters that we pass occasionally - loud red billboards featuring raised fists, grimly heroic faces, and the beatific gleam of the Great Leader (Kim Il Sung - his son, the current Dear Leader. Kim Jong Il, is not nearly as visible). Billboard
The mood on the buses is slightly subdued, but as we pass one of these billboards you can hear the frantic clicking of every camera. But the people seem shockingly normal. Kids run across a street in the same down coats our kids wear, and their moms chase after them, laughing.

Then, nothing for a good 20 minutes but a dreary winter landscape, which seems like it would be just as dreary in the summer. There are few people, and no other vehicles on the road. When we enter Pyongyang, we see people on the streets - but still almost no other vehicles. A convoy of buses led by several official vehicles is bound to attract attention, but it also seems likely that word of the Philharmonic’s arrival has preceded us. People stare as we drive by. A boy watches our bus go by, and I wave to him as we pass. Hey, this kid may just run home and tell his mom, I saw an American and he wasn’t a demon… he actually waved to me. The buildings remind me of East Berlin, an architectural wasteland but with the effect softened by the green, pink, and mustard colors of many of them. Driving over a bridge, we pass a flatbed truck crowded with at least a dozen students, who all wave at us.

The lack of traffic is unnerving. In many intersections, a police woman in a blue winter coat, fur hat and gloves, and surprisingly sexy boots points our convoy’s way with rapid, clipped movements of a red stick. (We’d see the occasional police man, as well, but they somehow didn’t pull off the boots as well.) After a while, I ask “has anyone seen a traffic light?”. There is a ripple of surprise - no, no one has seen any sign of either sidewalk lights or traffic lights. There is definitely a weird vibe to Pyongyang, a kind of Western ghost town feeling. I mean, there are 2 million people here, but it seems almost deserted.

Yanggakdo Hotel

Our hotel is across the river and apparently in the middle of nowhere. It is 40 stories tall, and we can’t help wondering what they need all those rooms for. We meet our “guides,” one for each 5 or 6 of us, and go to our rooms to unpack. The hotel is trying very hard to be a good Western-style hotel, but they just don’t have it right yet. They do have the BBC on the television, which is a surprise. But there’s no time to check it out - we all want to check out our media center connections and then there’s a performance at one of the big state theaters we’re being taken to.

The performance is typical North Korean music: a bowdlerized version of Korean folk song in cheesy orchestrations, over-amplified so it sounds like a recording, and accompanying dance or acrobatic routines that have a similar combination of the traditional and the tasteless. Traditional performanceThe performances themselves are impeccable - clearly everyone here is the product of years of serious training. After it’s over, Lorin Maazel comes onstage to present flowers to the prima ballerina. The hall, by the way, is an over-the-top behemoth, with a Soviet take on Classical architecture married to garish colored lights and a fake waterfall.

Then on to the banquet. Our itinerary includes all meals, mostly at the hotel, but this one is in a grand, old ballroom, where each table is set with plates of (to us) unrecognizable but presumably edible objects, and a centerpiece of bottles of water, soda, beer, and ginseng liquor. The latter is interesting. The local beer is quite palatable. The food - and I am an adventurous eater - ranges from the good (most of the Korean food) to the barely palatable (the “normal” foods, like salmon and mutton, both overcooked). There will be dessert and more drinks, but some of us need to get back to the media center to start filing or phoning in reports.

The Dark Side of the Moon, Part II

Technically, this trip continues to be an exercise in frustration. I lugged nearly 40 pounds of equipment and one of the big pieces, which makes a crappy phone line sound like a crappy live interview, was not working in Beijing yesterday. It apparently doesn’t like Asian phone service. This evening, everything that can go wrong does. I eventually get a few nice clips back via yousendit.com, but this takes most of the night, interspersed with live reports for Brian Lehrer and Soundcheck and Morning Edition and whatnot. I mean come on, how many shows do we have back there??? Zero hour is tomorrow - we don’t have a concert broadcast unless someone figures out how to get the audio from here to NY. The Philharmonic’s audio engineer, Larry Rock, is a nice guy, and more to the point, he’s resourceful - and a WNYC fan. If anyone can make this happen, Larry can. ‘Cause I certainly can’t…

Stumbling to bed in the early morning, the hotel seems abandoned. Our minders disappear in the evening to their rooms - after all, where can we go? There’s nothing around for at least a mile and it’s pitch black out. And of course there are no taxis. So hotel guests remain hotel guests until someone with a vehicle comes to get them. Very ingenious…

Beijing

February 25, 2008 – 1:54 am

Under other circumstances, the New York Philharmonic’s performance here tonight might be a story unto itself. But with the orchestra leaving tomorrow morning, with its press corps in tow, for the history-making concert in North Korea, tonight is simply a prelude to the main event.
Entrance to Forbidden City
Still, Beijing has proven to be an interesting place. The hotel most of us are staying in is near Tiananmen Square and the Forbidden City. A brisk walk will take you to both - one, the square, is simply a large open plaza surrounded by important but nondescript buildings. The other, though, is a massive complex of temples, palaces, pavilions, gardens and even larger open plazas that requires at least one whole day to take in.
Guardian Flaming Cat
Tonight’s concert took place at the new National Centre for the Performing Arts, just west of Tiananmen Square and the exact opposite of the stolid architecture that surrounds it. Known as the “floating pearl” or the “duck’s egg,” this in-your-face structure is not only visually controversial, it is financially and musically so. Now two months old, it was way over budget, and much ink has been spilled on whether this “National” center should focus on Chinese arts or international performers. The decision seems to be, for now at least, to try focusing on both - which of course means not focusing at all. So a mishmash of traditional music/dance events are lined up alongside the NY Phil, the London Symphony Orchestra (due shortly), and other decidedly un-Chinese attractions. Duck Egg
Anyway, the concert hall looks like a huge metal and glass egg half-submerged in a pond - with no visible means of entry from the street. (You actually go down stairs from street level to enter.). When you walk through the enormous foyer, the waters of the pond can be seen moving across the glass ceiling high above.
The concert was a big deal: at least 3 people asked - by means of pidgin English or sign language - if I would sell my ticket. (A young woman asked me something too, in Mandarin, but I’m pretty sure the concert wasn’t what she had in mind.) It couldn’t have been the program, which was fairly prosaic: Dvorak’s 7th and the Brahms 4th. But the NY Phil in Beijing, in the new space, in the year of the Beijing Olympics, was apparently a hot ticket.
Look What My Hat Can Do!
Tuesday will be another matter. At a press conference today, the Phil told us that they would not know if any “special guests” were coming until Monday or possibly Tuesday morning. It was a subtle reminder that Condoleezza Rice is leading a US government contingent to the inauguration of South Korea’s new president on Monday, so there will be representatives of the administration on the peninsula for the concert. Of course, the concert was okayed by the State Department last fall, when negotiations on dismantling Pyongyang’s nuclear weapons program seemed to be moving forward. Now, with the North missing a Dec 31 deadline, it may be deemed politically incorrect for Rice or any other top administration folks to show up.
We’ll just have to see what happens tomorrow…

Destination: Pyongyang

February 22, 2008 – 3:24 pm

Greetings and welcome to Soundcheck’s Pyongyang blog! For the next week, Soundcheck host John Schaefer will be part of the New York Philharmonic’s Asian 2008 entourage as the orchestra makes a grand overture of cultural diplomacy, performing a concert in North Korea. If the internet access that we’re promised actually works, and if there are no media-censoring firewalls in place, we hope to report on the impact that this concert from Pyongyang might have on U.S.-North Korean relations, share some pictures from the concert, and reflect upon the event.

Keep up with John Schaefer’s adventures from Asia –well, at least Beijing and the airport from Inchon, South Korea, come back often to see if maybe SMS messages or e-mails can make it out of North Korea, and talk back in our comments section. Welcome again!




Web tools supported by
Print friendly format
supported by

Listen Live
FM 93.9 Windows 20k
MP3 32k
AM 820 Windows 20k
MP3 32k
Shopping Online?
Start your Amazon shopping on WNYC.org and a portion of your total purchase goes to WNYC.


Categories
Archives
Search Blog
RSS Feeds