Soundcheck Blog

Monthly Archives: May 2008

Zeroes and Villains

May 29, 2008 – 1:16 pm

How did Blender do it? How did they start compiling a list of music’s creepiest, most repulsive, often genuinely criminal people – and stop at just 25? I don’t know what it is about the music biz, but it has long been a magnet for shady characters. I suppose it’s all the money flowing in and out for a commodity that is so slippery and elusive – the music industry basically made up its own rules as it went along, and changed them when it could if it suited the corporate bottom line. And fame does funny things to musicians, and often to their extended, even bloated, entourages.

And we listeners aren’t blameless in this either. Just like in the world of sports, we put our favorite musicians on pedestals and laugh off their idiosyncrasies as “part of the lifestyle”. Hey, if Phil Spector pulls a gun on you in a deserted parking lot or, say, in a bedroom in his home, will you excuse him because he did after all create the “wall of sound” and produced some of the greatest pop songs in the past half century? Plus he did the same thing to apparently half the musicians he’s produced over the years?

So how does Phil Spector NOT make it onto Blender’s list? Check out the list here – who do you think belongs on this list? (Yeah, yeah, I know – critics who make lists. What else you got?)

Tribute Bands: Even better than the real thing?

May 28, 2008 – 1:26 pm

I’ve never understood the whole tribute band thing. I also never understood the people who reenact Civil War battles, so maybe this is a blind spot of some sort… But to do someone else’s songs night after night, aping the sound of the original band, and sometimes even trying to look like the original band, strikes me as a little weird, and a little too much like dressing up for Halloween. Unless you’re being funny or ironic about it, in which case it becomes a novelty.

For me, the problem is that music in a live performance setting should be about playing in the moment, not recreating someone else’s moment years ago. And from what I’m told, most tribute bands (not cover bands, which are a different thing) do slavishly recreate the gestures, the solos, the drum fills, of the original recordings.

Key phrase in all this: “from what I’m told.” That’s right – I’ve never actually seen a tribute band live. If you have, feel free to tell me how I’ve gotten this all wrong…

One producer’s thoughts on 70’s female folkies

May 23, 2008 – 1:26 pm

Alysia AbbottWhen I prepared the segment on GIRLS LIKE US: Carole King, Joni Mitchell and Carly Simon – and the Journey of a Generation for Soundcheck I had no idea that it would resonate with me, a gen-Xer. Among the many stories author Sheila Weller novelistically recounts is how Joni Mitchell, then Joan Anderson, finds herself pregnant and unmarried at 20. 8 years before Roe vs. Wade, there were frighteningly few options for women in this predicament. Joni decides to give up her daughter, a painful decision, which, it’s suggested, may have fueled Mitchell’s remarkable career and artistry. My mother, who died in a car crash two years after Blue came out, found herself in the same situation, the same year as Joni Mitchell. Before she met my father, she became pregnant and unmarried she gave up her daughter (my unfound half-sister) for adoption.

As revealed in the book, Joni wrote about her daughter in Little Green, track 3 of Blue, a song I’d listened countless times without ever knowing what it was about.

“Child with a child pretending
Weary of lies you are sending home
So you sign all the papers in the family name
You’re sad and you’re sorry, but you’re not ashamed
Little green, have a happy ending”

Today I’m happily married, with a baby boy and toddler girl, who’s roughly my age when I lost my mother. Reading these lyrics, really for the first time, I finally have a sense of what both my mother and Joni went through, along with presumably many women of their generation.

“There’ll be icicles and birthday clothes
And sometimes there’ll be so-rrow.”

Alysia Abbott

Tell us: Have you ever made sense of your life by listening to music?

John on the In-Store Experience

May 22, 2008 – 2:21 pm

Record stores are great. If you already know what you like and what you’re looking for. Otherwise, buying music online has a huge advantage. Old-timers talk about walking into their local record shop and being intrigued by an album cover and asking the guy behind the counter to play a track before buying it. Well, I used to buy LPs in my local record store, and I NEVER had that experience. Whatever was on the turntable is what you listened to while browsing. I would’ve loved the opportunity to hear 30 seconds from any track I was interested in, as you can do online.

So, even though our listener poll is unscientific, I also find it unsurprising that only 14% of our respondents buy their music exclusively in brick-and-mortar stores. 77% either shopped exclusively online or used a combination of the two. (The other 9%? Apparently living in a monastery under a vow of silence.)

Believe me, I understand the nostalgia for album art and liner notes and all that. But as the Italians say, “prima la musica” – plus those mp3 files are SO much easier to store!

Did you miss out on our poll? Check it out and let us know what you think – where and how do you get your music fix?

History in the Making

May 21, 2008 – 12:55 pm

Usually you don’t realize you’re witnessing history until time has past and events have become historic. (There are obvious exceptions.) Suze Rotolo couldn’t have known she was witnessing history when her boyfriend, a young folksinger named Bob Dylan, got a good review in the New York Times. And she certainly didn’t expect to be part of an image that captured that moment in history when the ’60s began to wake up and move to the sounds of youthful disaffection and rage and enthusiasm and belief. But there she is, frozen in time as Bob Dylan’s 19-year-old girlfriend on the famous album cover of “The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan,” the album that changed the soundtrack of the 60s.

london-calling.jpgLike I said, usually you don’t know when history is unfolding. For me, traveling to North Korea with the NY Philharmonic earlier this year was obviously a chance to witness history. But none of us who were at the old Palladium the night a Clash concert ended with fans rushing the stage and the musicians smashing their instruments knew we were witnessing another iconic moment –- until it was captured on another famous album cover, The Clash’s “London Calling.”

Tell us: Have you been there when music history has been made? A career launched? Or ended? A style evolves, or a one-time confluence of talent shares a stage? And how long before you realized it?

Film Composers: Raiders of the Lost Art?

May 20, 2008 – 11:22 am

Harrison Ford as Indiana JonesFilm scores and classical music. The question is, can the former also be considered the latter. Sort of depends on your definition of “classical music,” doesn’t it? Fully notated music for an orchestra requires the composer to have basic techniques of what I think everyone would comfortably term classical music – things like voice-leading, orchestration, etc. But if that’s all that’s required to call it classical music, then all those Frank Sinatra records with Nelson Riddle would fit the bill. (Hmmm…. “It Was A Very Good Year”? I’ll go for that. But then what about sappy clunkers like “There Used To Be A Ballpark Here”?)

For the vast majority of Americans, the only time they actively listen to an orchestra is when John Williams is conducting it and the horns are drowning out the unearthly shrieks of a Tyrannosaurus Rex. Purists may shudder (after all, that’s what purists do), but for those audiences, listening to that music later at home is a kind of classical music experience.

What do you think? If a film score is orchestral and grand, is it classical music? (Even if that means just bad classical music?) What if it’s electronic? Click here to leave a comment.

The Search for Rebel Girls

May 19, 2008 – 1:32 pm

Cat PowerWhere are the women in rock? I happen to know they’re still out there – I share an office with one, as you may have learned in our posting last Wednesday – but Women Who Rock just don’t seem to be as visible as they were 15 years ago, when Bikini Kill and Sleater-Kinney were leading the charge of the riot-grrls in the Pacific Northwest and Courtney Love’s Hole was taking no prisoners. Women in music now? Well, there’s Britney and her ilk, or there are undeniable and genuinely musical forces like Feist and Cat Power. But where is that amps-up-to-11, pin-your-ears-to-the-wall sound that once proved that gender had nothing to do with your ability to rock? And if it really IS gone, what’s wrong with that? Does rockin’ hard define a woman any more than anything else? Tell us what you think. (Cat Power photo: Stefano Giovannini)

Toying With Musical Skill

May 16, 2008 – 11:47 am

rock_band_image.jpgWhen the Soundcheck crew went to play the videogame Rock Band, I was struck by how truly sucky I was when, as a lifelong guitarist, I picked the Rock Band guitar controller. I quickly realized, there is no correlation between playing Rock Band (or its guitar-only big brother, Guitar Hero) and playing a real instrument. Move to the microphone, though, and you are really singing; sit behind the drum pads, and you’re really drumming. Will playing this interactive game actually teach you to sing or to drum? Maybe not by itself, but it seems like it might be good practice.

So what to make of Virtual Maestro? Now you can conduct a virtual orchestra, making it slow down or speed up. But you can’t tell the horns to enter a bit more quietly, or to ask the first clarinet to hold that last note just a tiny bit more, until the oboe is in. Like the guitar controller in Rock Band, the baton here is a plastic toy. You can play with it, but I don’t think you can learn from it.

Of course, no one is claiming you SHOULD learn from these music simulators. They are games, after all. The question is, are they good for music? Will they spark interest in really learning to make music? Or do they offer an easy way out to people who might otherwise do the hard work of learning and practicing an instrument?

Tell us: What do you think?

Buy John Some Peanuts and Crackerjack

May 15, 2008 – 1:48 pm

You know the song “Heart And Soul”? Sure you do – it’s the one every beginning pianist sits down and bangs out on the keyboard at school assemblies and the like. Or maybe you don’t… what everyone knows is the chorus of “Heart And Soul.” But there are verses, verses I never heard until the legendary jazz pianist Marian McPartland played the whole song for us in our studio back in the 90s, when she was a mere 121 years old. (Her series “Piano Jazz” has been a public radio fixture for decades – no exaggeration.)

Anyway, “Take Me Out To The Ballgame” is another of those songs we all THINK we know – but again, it’s just the chorus. Today, we’ll hear some of those long lost verses too. I don’t know about you, but I like finding out new stuff about thrice-familiar songs.

Do you have any other examples of songs that are familiar, popular, or just personal favorites, but that turned out to have another side to them?

It’s Easy Being John

May 14, 2008 – 1:42 pm

Well, I certainly don’t want to get in trouble here, but I also don’t want to get anyone else in trouble either, so I’m going to leave my all-purpose assistant, Caryn Havlik, out of this. Let me just say that even with all the music that comes into my office – more than I could ever actually listen to – there are sometimes bands or records I want that I can’t easily put my hands on. I’ve found that if I tell my anonymous assistant about this band or record, it will quite often appear on a burned CD on my desk later that day. I believe she is able to accomplish this because she is a musician herself and therefore knows every musician in the universe, living or dead. I believe this in a sincere and legally-binding way.

It’s all about Plausible Deniability, people…


« Older posts

Web tools supported by
Print friendly format
supported by

Listen Live
FM 93.9 Windows 20k
MP3 32k
AM 820 Windows 20k
MP3 32k
Shopping Online?
Start your Amazon shopping on WNYC.org and a portion of your total purchase goes to WNYC.


Categories
Archives
Search Blog
RSS Feeds